Angling in Red Dead Redemption 2 provides players with a serene escape from the rugged outlaw life, but landing a Legendary Fish introduces a distinct challenge. Once you reel in one of these massive aquatic creatures, deciding what to do next is crucial for completing side quests and earning unique rewards. Knowing how to properly manage your catch ensures you make steady progress toward full game completion.
Mailing Your Catch to Jeremy Gill
The primary destination for any Legendary Fish is the nearest post office. These rare catches are part of "A Fisher of Fish," a stranger mission given by famous angler Jeremy Gill at his cabin along Flat Iron Lake. After securing a prize specimen, stow it on the back of your horse and head directly to a train station or post office to mail it to him.
Mailing each specimen registers your achievement in the game log and triggers progress for the overarching questline. Keep in mind that smaller legendary species can fit inside your satchel, while larger ones must be carried individually on your mount. Transporting heavy fish quickly prevents accidental loss due to unexpected encounters or mishaps in the wilderness.
Unlocking Rewards and Completion Milestones
Sending Legendary Fish to Jeremy Gill offers direct incentives beyond mere quest progression. As you reach specific milestones in the quest line, Mr. Gill sends cash rewards and specialized lures back through the mail. Completing the entire collection eventually unlocks the final phase of his mission, leading to a memorable encounter and exclusive gear.
In addition to quest rewards, catching and submitting every unique fish is mandatory for players aiming for 100 percent game completion. It also fulfills requirements for higher-tier Survivalist challenges, proving Arthur's mastery over the frontier's ecosystems. Tracking your progress through the map map and log ensures no region is left unexplored.
Handling Lost or Damaged Legendary Fish
It is not uncommon to lose a prize catch due to predator attacks, ambushes, or accidental horse falls. If you perish while carrying a Legendary Fish, the physical carcass will disappear from your horse's back. However, the game automatically marks the fish as caught in your logbook, so you will not permanently miss out on quest credit.
If the item vanishes before you can post it, check your map to see if the icon is crossed out. A crossed-out icon confirms that the game has recorded your accomplishment, meaning you do not need to recapture it. Understanding this mechanic helps alleviate frustration during treacherous journeys across the frontier.
Tips for Safe Transportation Across the Map
Transporting large catches across vast distances requires careful planning to avoid unnecessary risks. Avoid traveling through known gang territory or areas densely populated by dangerous predators like cougars and gators. Fast travel options from campsites or stagecoaches can significantly reduce transit times and protect your haul.
Always secure your horse before skinning or fishing nearby to prevent your mount from wandering off with valuable cargo. If you plan a long fishing trip, prioritize visiting the nearest post office immediately after each successful catch. Establishing a disciplined routine ensures every Legendary Fish reaches its intended recipient safely.